Home / Research / Local AI answers study

Research · November 2026 wave

Local AI answers study

I asked four AI assistants "Who is the best [profession] in [city]?" for 5 professions in 25 US cities, two times each. That is 1,000 answers. This page shows which businesses and professionals the assistants name, which sources they cite, and how much the answers change.

Key findings

Four assistants, four different lists

79.7%
of the businesses and professionals named were named by only one of the four assistants (3,696 of 4,635)
1.5%
were named by all four assistants (69 of 4,635)
0%
of questions got the same list of names from ChatGPT two times in a row (0 of 124)
92%
of Google AI Mode answers linked to a Google Maps listing (230 of 250). The other three assistants linked to none
  • The assistants rarely agree. Across 125 questions they named 4,635 businesses and professionals. 79.7% came from one assistant only, 13.7% from two, 5.1% from three and 1.5% from all four.
  • But almost each market has a shared name. In 92% of questions (115 of 125), one name or more came from three assistants or more. In 39.2% (49 of 125), one name came from all four.
  • The same question gives a different answer the next time. When I asked again a few seconds later, the first name in the answer was the same in 52.7% of cases (255 of 484).
  • Most of the different sites are local, but they get the smaller part of the citations. The answers linked to 1,153 different sites. 84.5% of them appeared for one city only (974 of 1,153). Sites that appeared for one or two cities got 36.9% of the citations (1,914 of 5,189).
  • A small group of sites gets most citations. 124 sites other than Google Maps appeared for 3 cities or more. They got 58.7% of the citations (3,045 of 5,189). Google Maps listings got 4.4%.
  • Yelp and Facebook are almost absent as sources. 2.6% of answers linked to Yelp as a source (26 of 1,000). ChatGPT and Gemini never linked to it. No answer linked to Facebook (0 of 1,000). An answer can still name Yelp or Facebook in its text.

Agreement

How many assistants name the same business?

Share of the 4,635 businesses and professionals named, by the number of assistants that named each one. Both runs of each assistant are counted.
One assistant only79.7% 3,696 names
Two assistants13.7% 634
Three assistants5.1% 236
All four assistants1.5% 69

For a local business this means one assistant is not "AI". A business that ChatGPT names can be absent from Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Mode for the same question on the same day. A person and that person's firm count as two names here, which makes agreement look lower than it is. The limits give the size of that error.

Consistency

Ask the same question two times

Each question went to each assistant two times, a few seconds apart. The table compares the two answers.

The same question asked two times, for each assistant
AssistantSame list of namesSame first nameNames in both answers (mean)No name in commonCited sites in both answers (mean)
Google AI Mode1.6% 2 of 12531.5% 39 of 12435.6%10.4%76.9%
ChatGPT0% 0 of 12445.9% 51 of 11129.6%13.7%51.5%
Gemini1.6% 2 of 12548.8% 61 of 12541.4%0.8%55.5%
Perplexity24% 30 of 12583.9% 104 of 12469.8%0.8%99.3%

"Names in both answers" is the count of names in both answers divided by the count in one or the other. Perplexity used the same sources in the same order in 116 of 125 pairs, but it wrote new text each time. No assistant gave the same text two times.

Sources

What each assistant cites

I sorted each cited site into one of three groups. A Google Maps listing is a link to a business listing on Google. A multi-market site was cited for 3 cities or more in this study: directories, ranking sites, review sites and publishers. A local site was cited for one or two cities. In a sample of 40 of these, 33 were the website of one business and the others were local directories or publishers. Google AI Mode answers come from Google search results and the other three from each provider's API, so the form of the sources is not the same.

Share of answers that cite each kind of source, for each assistant
AssistantGoogle Maps listingMulti-market siteLocal siteOnly multi-market sitesSites per answer (mean)Businesses per answer (mean)
Google AI Mode92%18.8%6%4.4%1.236.54
ChatGPT0%99.2%68.8%31.2%5.2911.05
Gemini0%98.8%99.6%0.4%7.8410.96
Perplexity0%100%86.4%13.6%6.44.69

The 25 most cited sites

Sites cited most often in all 1,000 answers
SiteShare of answersAnswersCitiesGoogle AI ModeChatGPTGeminiPerplexity
google.com23%23025230000
expertise.com12.9%129240831036
energysage.com12.8%128244393748
healthgrades.com11.4%11425060054
clearlyrated.com11.3%113242283548
doctor.webmd.com11.1%11125013890
solarreviews.com10.2%102254363824
clutch.co9.6%96250193146
dentistsranked.com9.5%9525050936
reviews.birdeye.com8.7%8722077100
ecowatch.com8.6%8624043844
justia.com8.6%8625004244
attorneys.superlawyers.com7.7%77253174116
bestinhood.com7%7012044026
reddit.com6.8%6822043250
bestlawfirms.com6.1%6122061639
bestlawyers.com5.6%562500650
zocdoc.com5.1%511738832
bbb.org5%501800050
avvo.com4.5%452404302
dentascore.com4.5%4519035010
forbes.com4.5%4515002322
thumbtack.com4.4%44181311218
serviceagent.ai4.1%411709320
hearingup.com3.8%3817002810

The last four columns show the number of answers from each assistant that cited the site, out of 250. google.com here means Google Maps listings.

By profession

Results for each profession

Key measures for each profession
ProfessionNamed by one assistant onlyA business named by 3+ assistantsAnswers that cite a local siteMost cited site
Dentist79.3%96%65.5%dentistsranked.com 47.5%
Audiologist78.4%88%71.5%healthgrades.com 42%
Personal injury lawyer86.2%84%63%justia.com 43%
Accountant77%92%64.5%clearlyrated.com 56.5%
Solar installer74.9%100%61.5%energysage.com 64%

By city size

Key measures for each city size
City sizeNamed by one assistant onlyA business named by 3+ assistantsSame first business on the second run
City population over 1,000,00080.9%95%51.6%
City population from 300,000 to 1,000,00080.4%91.1%51.7%
City population under 300,00077.4%90%54.9%

By assistant

Results for each assistant

Data

Download the data and cite it

The dataset has one row for each of the 1,000 answers: the question, the assistant, the model, the time, the number of businesses and professionals named, the number of cited sites, and the name of each cited site that appeared for 3 cities or more. The findings file holds each number on these pages with its count and its base.

The answer text and the names of the businesses are not in the public files. The methodology says why. To cite this study:

LiButti, Cameron. "Local AI Answers Study." November 2026 wave, published November 18, 2026. cameronlibutti.com. https://cameronlibutti.com/research/local-ai-answers/

Collected November 18, 2026. The plan is one new wave each month, with the same questions and cities. The methodology has the question list, the cities, the models, the limits and the corrections policy.

Author

Who ran the study

I'm Cameron LiButti, a former mechanical engineer and the founder of Bidview Marketing. My team works on how local businesses show up in AI answers, so I wanted numbers that do not come from our own clients. No Bidview client is inside a city of this study. Some clients are in suburbs of Houston, Denver and Chicago. More about my method is on the marketing engineer page. Found an error? Use the contact page.